Insights / Capacity decisions
New Line or More From the Lines You Have?
Before investing in a new line, find out how much time the existing lines lose and whether those losses sit on the stage that limits the plant. Recovering lost time on that stage is usually cheaper and faster than a new line, and it can cover a large part of the extra output needed. A new line is the right answer when demand growth exceeds what can be recovered, or when the plant needs something the current lines cannot do. This guide sets out how to tell which situation you are in.
Step 1: size the gap
Write down exactly how much extra output is needed, by when, and for which products and pack formats. “We need more capacity” leads to a new line by default. “We need 20% more of the 500 g range from next September” can be tested against several options.
Check whether the gap is permanent. A seasonal peak or a single large contract may be better covered by stock build, extra shifts or co-packing than by fixed equipment.
Step 2: find the real constraint
Every plant has one stage that sets its output at any given time. Improving any other stage adds nothing until that one is dealt with. This is the core idea of the theory of constraints, and it is an easy step to skip.
The constraint is often not the stage everyone points to. It can be a cooking vessel, a buffer tank, a cleaning-in-place set shared by several tanks, a crew moving between lines, or the palletiser at the end. It can also move as the product mix changes. Signs to look for:
- material queues upstream of it, and the stages after it often wait
- it is rarely starved of input or blocked by the stage after it
- when it stops, plant output drops straight away
On a chocolate moulding line we modelled, not everything that looked like a bottleneck on the floor turned out to be one. Widening the line only paid back if the widened section was what was holding output down.
Step 3: measure the losses on that stage
Overall equipment effectiveness (OEE) splits lost time into three parts: availability (stops and changeovers), performance (running below rated speed and short stops) and quality (rejects and rework). OEE is the three multiplied together.
An illustrative line running at 75% availability, 85% performance and 91% quality has an OEE of 58%. The table shows what improving each factor would add.
| Change on the constraint | New OEE | Extra output |
|---|---|---|
| Today: 75% × 85% × 91% | 58.0% | None |
| Availability to 85% (shorter changeovers, fewer breakdowns) | 65.7% | +13.3% |
| Performance to 92% (fewer short stops, running nearer rated speed) | 62.8% | +8.2% |
| Quality to 95% | 60.6% | +4.4% |
| Availability to 85% and performance to 92% | 71.2% | +22.7% |
These gains only reach the plant’s output if the line is the constraint. Raising OEE on a line that is waiting for product from an upstream tank only makes it wait longer.
Step 4: list every option
| Option | Capital | Lead time | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| More running time: extra shifts or weekends | None | Weeks | Labour cost and availability, less time for maintenance and cleaning |
| Shorter changeovers (SMED) and better sequencing | Low | Weeks to months | Needs a sequence the schedule can hold to |
| Fewer breakdowns and short stops | Low to medium | Months | Gains are spread over many small causes |
| Rationalising the product range | None | Months | Commercial agreement; customers of the dropped lines |
| Moving products between lines or sites | Low | Months | Moves the constraint somewhere else |
| Debottlenecking the constraint (one machine, a tank, a conveyor) | Medium | Months | The next constraint appears; check what it is |
| Widening or speeding up an existing line | Medium to high | Months, with downtime | Installation disruption and stock build |
| New line | High | Often a year or more | Shared upstream and downstream capacity, ramp-up |
The options can be combined. A package of resequencing, a debottleneck on one stage and a range review can cover the gap for a fraction of the cost of a line.
Step 5: compare on the same basis
For each option, estimate the extra annual output it gives on the constraint, the capital and operating cost, the lead time and the risk. Then compare cost per extra tonne or unit, and NPV over the same period. Our guide to building the business case for a new line covers the financial side.
Check each option for the next constraint. Removing one bottleneck exposes the next, and the extra output stops where that one starts. An option that looks like 25% may deliver 10% before something else limits it.
When a new line is the right answer
- Demand growth is larger than the capacity that can be recovered from existing lines.
- The plant needs a format, process or speed the current lines cannot provide.
- Hygiene or allergen separation requires dedicated equipment.
- A single line carries too much risk, and a second one is needed for resilience.
- Existing lines are near the end of their life and need replacing anyway.
- Extra shifts are not possible because of labour availability or site restrictions.
What our projects found in existing plants
- Toothpaste tube filling: 30% more production output from identifying and dealing with the real capacity constraints, with a £1M investment validated before it was committed.
- Vinegar: 15% more throughput and 56% less idle time from scheduling and relieving tank bottlenecks, while reducing the number of storage tanks.
- Pickles and condiments: enough capacity found to move from 24/7 to 24/5 operation, through resequencing and range rationalisation.
- Chocolate moulding: a widening tested before any money was spent, showing it would support 20% more output and which constraint would come next.
Common questions
What is a good OEE figure?
85% is often quoted as world class for discrete manufacturing, and many plants run well below it. Compare a line with its own history and with similar lines in the plant rather than with a general benchmark, because OEE depends heavily on how it is measured and on the product mix.
Does adding a shift count as more capacity?
Yes. It is usually the fastest option and needs no capital, but it adds labour cost every year and reduces the time available for maintenance and cleaning. Compare it with the other options over the same period.
How do we find the constraint if it keeps moving?
A shifting constraint usually means the product mix or the schedule is moving it. A factory model shows where the constraint sits for each mix and schedule, which is hard to see from line data alone.
Related guides
- Cutting changeover time by resequencing production: capacity recovered without capital.
- How to build the business case for a new production line: if a new line is the answer.
- Capacity planning without spreadsheets: why averages hide the constraint.