Insights / Automation

Will Automating the Packing Line Pay Back?

Packing automation is usually justified on labour, and the labour saving is the easiest part to calculate. What decides whether it pays back is what the automation does to the line’s output. A cell that adds a few percent of downtime to a busy line can wipe out the labour saving, and one that lets a constrained line run faster can pay back in half the time. This guide shows how to cost both sides, with a worked example using UK labour costs for 2026.

Where the savings come from

  • Labour. Operator roles removed per shift, multiplied by shifts, at fully loaded cost.
  • Labour availability. Repetitive packing and palletising roles can be hard to fill and keep filled. Automation reduces exposure to that.
  • Consistency. Fewer damaged cases, more accurate pack counts and less giveaway.
  • Health and safety. Less repetitive lifting, which reduces injury risk and absence.
  • Output. Higher or steadier speed at the end of the line, if the end of the line is what limits output.

Labour is the easiest of these to put a figure on. Output is the one that most often decides the result, in either direction.

Cost labour fully

From 1 April 2026 the National Living Wage is £12.71 an hour. Packing operators are often paid above it. Using an illustrative £13.50 an hour on a 37.5-hour week:

Item Annual cost
Gross pay: £13.50 × 37.5 hours × 52 weeks £26,325
Employer National Insurance: 15% above £5,000 £3,199
Employer pension: 3% of qualifying earnings £603
Subtotal £30,127
Recruitment, training, PPE and absence cover (estimate) about £1,900
Fully loaded cost per operator role about £32,000

Use your own payroll figures where you have them. Costing a role from gross pay alone understates it by around 18% in this example.

Count the roles that actually go

Automation removes a task. Whether it removes a role depends on what else that person did. Check, shift by shift:

  • Does the operator also do changeovers, material replenishment, quality checks or cleaning? Those tasks remain.
  • Does the cell need someone to load packaging materials, clear jams or watch it?
  • Will the cell need more maintenance or controls skill than the site has now?
  • Is holiday and absence cover included in the headcount you are removing?

When a biscuit manufacturer we worked with planned a £3M Lean redesign with more automation, crewing was worked out in the model for each option. That identified where automation genuinely took labour out, and where it only moved the same work to another point on the line.

A worked example

The figures are illustrative. A food manufacturer is considering a robotic case packing and palletising cell costing £650,000 installed. The line runs two shifts a day, five days a week, 48 weeks a year: 3,840 running hours. Each running hour earns £600 of contribution.

  • The cell removes five operator roles across the two shifts: £160,000 a year at £32,000 each.
  • It needs half a technician’s time (£24,000) and £25,000 a year of maintenance and spares.
  • Net labour saving: £111,000 a year.
Scenario Annual benefit Simple payback
Labour saving only, line output unchanged £111,000 5.9 years
Cell adds 3% downtime to the line (new jams and stops) £41,900 15.5 years
Line is constrained at packing, cell lifts output 5% and the extra can be sold £226,200 2.9 years

On labour alone, the cell pays back in just under six years, and over eight years at a 10% discount rate its NPV is slightly negative. A 3% loss of line time costs £69,000 a year in contribution, which takes most of the labour saving with it. A 5% gain in output on a constrained line is worth £115,000 a year, more than the labour saving itself.

The decision therefore turns on two questions: is packing the constraint on this line, and will the cell run more reliably than the people it replaces? Neither can be answered from a supplier’s rated speed.

What automation does to line output

Automated cells stop in different ways from manual stations. A manual station slows down when something goes wrong, while an automated cell usually stops. Short stops caused by packaging material variation, product orientation or case erectors are common in the first months, and each one can stop the line if there is no accumulation before the cell.

Things to check before buying:

  • Is the end of the line the constraint? If the filler or an upstream batch process limits output, a faster packer adds no output, and the case rests on labour alone.
  • Accumulation. Conveyor space before the cell lets the upstream line keep running through short stops. Without it, every jam stops the line.
  • Speed matching. The cell should run a little faster than the line feeding it, so it can catch up after a stop.
  • Changeovers. Format parts and recipe changes on the cell may be faster or slower than the manual process. Check against your real product mix.
  • Ramp-up. Reliability in the first months is usually lower than the supplier’s figure. Include it in the first year’s output.

A model of the line, with the cell’s stop patterns and the accumulation before it, shows the output change for each of these before the order is placed.

Capital cost: what to include

  • the cell, grippers and format parts for every pack you run
  • guarding, safety systems and risk assessment
  • conveyors and accumulation
  • integration with the line’s controls and any labelling or traceability systems
  • floor space, and any building or services work
  • installation, commissioning, training and critical spares
  • lost production while the cell is installed

In the UK, companies can claim full expensing on new and unused main-rate plant and machinery, a 100% first-year deduction. A 40% first-year allowance has also applied since 1 January 2026, including for unincorporated businesses. At the 25% main rate of corporation tax, full expensing on a £650,000 cell is worth about £162,500 of relief in the first year if the company has enough taxable profit. Confirm the treatment of each item with your accountant.

What our projects found

  • Biscuits: a £3M redesign with more automation tested before it was committed, with labour savings identified where the automation actually reduced crewing.
  • Ration pack assembly: a 20% reduction in crewing levels from optimised shift patterns and cross-line labour allocation, found in the model of a new facility.
  • Toothpaste tube filling and packing: 30% more output from finding the constraints that were really setting the line’s ceiling, and a £1M spend validated before it was committed.

Common questions

What payback should we expect from packing automation?

There is no reliable typical figure, because it depends on shifts, wages, the cell’s reliability and whether packing limits output. The example above ranges from under three years to over fifteen on the same cell. Use your own figures and test the output assumption.

Should we start with palletising?

End-of-line palletising is a common first step because the work is repetitive and heavy, it has fewer format changes than primary packing, and a stop there is often easier to buffer. Check it against your own line before assuming it is the best place to start.

Does running more shifts make automation pay back faster?

Yes, in proportion to the roles removed per shift. A cell that replaces two operators per shift saves twice as much on a two-shift pattern as on one. It also has more hours to stop in, so reliability matters more.

Related guides

Test the automation in a model