Insights / Capital investment

How to Build the Business Case for a New Production Line

The business case for a new line depends on one figure more than any other: how much the line will really produce once it is installed, ramped up and running alongside the rest of the plant. Payback, NPV and IRR all follow from that figure with simple arithmetic. If it is wrong, every number in the paper is wrong in the same direction. This guide sets out what a board expects to see, how to build each part, and where line business cases usually go wrong.

What the board needs to see

Finance teams differ in format, but a capital request for a production line nearly always has to answer the same questions:

  • The need. What demand or cost problem the investment solves, with the volumes behind it.
  • The options. What else was considered, including doing nothing and getting more out of the lines you already have.
  • Output. How much the new line will produce per year, and how that figure was arrived at.
  • Capital cost. Equipment, installation, services, building work, commissioning and contingency.
  • Operating cost and benefit. Labour, energy, maintenance, materials, waste and the contribution from extra sales.
  • Financial measures. Payback, net present value (NPV) and internal rate of return (IRR), on the company’s own discount rate.
  • Risk. Which assumptions the result is most sensitive to, and what happens if they are wrong.
  • Delivery. Installation plan, disruption to existing production, ramp-up and any stock build to cover it.

Ask finance for the hurdle rate, the maximum payback period they will accept and the appraisal period before you start. Building the case to the wrong rate wastes a round of review.

Start with the demand and the options

A new line is one answer to a capacity or cost problem. A request that compares a new line only against doing nothing invites the question of what else was tried, because there are usually cheaper options in between: removing the constraint on an existing line, cutting changeover time, changing the shift pattern or moving products between lines.

Put those options in the paper with their own cost and output, even if you expect to reject them. If the new line still wins, the case is stronger for it. If it does not, you have saved the money. Our guide to deciding between a new line and more from the lines you have covers how to compare them.

Output: the number everything else depends on

Supplier quotes give a rated speed. A business case needs annual output, and the gap between the two is large. Work it out in this order:

  1. Rated speed. Units per minute or kilograms per hour at the design speed, for each product the line will run.
  2. Planned running time. Shifts, days and weeks per year, less planned maintenance, cleaning and hygiene stops.
  3. Changeovers. How many per week the product mix will need, and how long each takes. This depends on the sequence, so it should come from a schedule, not a single average. See cutting changeover time by resequencing.
  4. Availability, performance and quality losses. Breakdowns, short stops, running below rated speed, rejects and rework. If you have OEE data from a similar line, use it. A new line rarely beats the plant’s existing lines in its first years.
  5. Interaction with the rest of the plant. A new filling line still needs product from the same tanks, the same cooking vessels, the same palletiser, the same cleaning-in-place (CIP) set and the same warehouse. If any of those is shared, the line’s output is limited by it.
  6. Ramp-up. Output in the first year is lower while the line is commissioned, operators learn it and faults are fixed. Show the ramp explicitly instead of assuming full output from month one.

Point 5 is the hardest to get right in a spreadsheet. A spreadsheet treats each line as if it runs on its own. In a real plant, the new line competes with existing lines for upstream capacity and for crews, and the buffer tanks or conveyors between stages decide how much of its rated speed survives. Our guide on capacity planning without spreadsheets explains why averages overstate output.

Capital cost: what to include

  • Equipment, as quoted, with the supplier’s exclusions listed and priced separately.
  • Installation, mechanical and electrical, including integration with existing controls.
  • Services: power supply upgrades, compressed air, steam, water, drainage and CIP connections.
  • Building work: floor, walls, ceilings, hygiene zoning and any extension.
  • Commissioning, validation and operator training.
  • Critical spare parts for the first years.
  • Project management and engineering time, internal and external.
  • Lost production on existing lines during installation, and the stock build needed to cover it.
  • Contingency, sized to how early the estimate is. Early estimates are less certain and need more.

The stock build is easy to forget. When a biscuit manufacturer we worked with prepared a £3M Lean redesign of one of its lines, the rebuild meant building stock to cover the gap in supply, which ties up cash and eats into shelf life. The transition was planned in the model to keep supply going on the least stock build.

Operating costs and benefits

List every annual cash flow that changes because of the investment, and only those:

  • Contribution from extra volume. Selling price less variable cost (materials, packaging, energy per unit, distribution), multiplied by the extra volume you can sell.
  • Labour. Crewing per shift for the new line, and any change on existing lines. Use fully loaded cost, including employer National Insurance, pension and holiday cover.
  • Energy, maintenance and consumables for the new equipment.
  • Yield and waste. A better line may waste less. A new line may waste more during ramp-up.
  • Working capital. Stock levels can rise or fall depending on the line’s flexibility and the size of production runs.

Keep the contribution figure honest. Extra volume only has value if the market will take it at the assumed price. If the line replaces old equipment instead of adding volume, the benefit is the cost saved, not new contribution.

A worked example

The figures below are illustrative. A food manufacturer is considering a new line costing £2.4M installed. It is rated at 3,000 tonnes a year of extra output, each tonne earns £300 of contribution, and the line adds £280,000 a year of fixed operating cost (crew, maintenance and energy). The company appraises over 10 years at a 10% discount rate.

Case Annual output Steady annual cash flow Payback NPV at 10% IRR
Rated output from day one 3,000 t £620,000 3.9 years +£1.41M 22.4%
Rated output, with ramp-up (50% in year 1, 80% in year 2) 3,000 t £620,000 5 years +£0.85M 16.7%
Realistic output (80% of rated) with the same ramp-up 2,400 t £440,000 7 years −£0.14M 8.8%

The first row is what a supplier quote and a simple spreadsheet produce. The third row is what happens when the line achieves 80% of its rated output once it shares tanks, crews and a palletiser with the rest of the plant. The investment moves from clearly worth doing to below the hurdle rate.

The break-even point in this example is about 2,490 tonnes a year, or 83% of rated output. That is the most useful single number in the paper, because it tells the board what has to be true for the investment to pay. If nobody can say with confidence whether the line will run above or below 83% of its rating, the case is not ready.

Tax relief on plant and machinery in the UK

Capital allowances change when the relief arrives, which changes NPV. As of November 2026:

  • Full expensing remains available to companies: 100% first-year relief on new and unused main-rate plant and machinery, with no cap.
  • A new 40% first-year allowance has applied since 1 January 2026 to new main-rate plant and machinery, including for unincorporated businesses and assets bought for leasing.
  • The main-rate writing-down allowance fell from 18% to 14% from 1 April 2026 for corporation tax, so expenditure that does not qualify for first-year relief is relieved more slowly.

For a company paying the 25% main rate of corporation tax with enough taxable profit, full expensing on £2.4M of qualifying plant brings about £600,000 of tax relief into the first year. Second-hand equipment does not qualify for full expensing or the 40% allowance. Confirm the treatment of each item with your accountant, because building work and integral features are treated differently from machinery.

Sensitivity and risk

Run the case again with each main assumption moved up and down: output, contribution per unit, capital cost, ramp-up length and labour. Show the board which ones move NPV most. In line investments the output assumption usually moves it more than any other.

In the example above, a 15% capital overrun on the realistic case takes NPV to about −£0.50M. A 20% shortfall in output, on the other hand, was enough on its own to turn a strong case into a weak one. The effort in a business case should go into the output figure before the capex quotes are refined further.

How a factory model changes the output figure

A model of the plant runs the new line with the rest of the factory: the shared tanks and vessels, the crews, the changeovers your product mix will need, and real stoppage patterns. It gives an output figure that already accounts for the interactions a spreadsheet leaves out, and it shows which constraint will appear next once the line is in.

Three examples from our own projects:

  • Ration pack assembly facility: £4M of cost identified against the spreadsheet-based design before it was approved, with equipment right-sized and a 20% reduction in crewing levels.
  • Toothpaste tube filling: a £1M investment validated against modelled performance before it was committed, after the model found 30% more output from dealing with the real constraints.
  • Chocolate moulding: a tested case for widening the line, covering the 20% extra output it would support and the constraint that would take over next.

Checklist before the paper goes to the board

  • The options include doing nothing and getting more from existing lines.
  • Annual output is built up from running time, changeovers and losses, not from rated speed.
  • Shared upstream and downstream equipment has been checked for capacity.
  • Ramp-up is shown year by year.
  • Capital cost includes services, building work, commissioning, disruption and stock build.
  • Labour is costed fully loaded.
  • Payback, NPV and IRR use finance’s discount rate and appraisal period.
  • The break-even output is stated, with the evidence for why the line will exceed it.
  • Capital allowances have been confirmed with the tax team.

Common questions

What discount rate should we use?

Use the rate finance gives you, usually the company’s cost of capital or a hurdle rate set above it. Use the same rate for every option so they can be compared.

Should payback or NPV decide?

NPV measures how much value the investment creates. Payback measures how quickly the cash comes back, which matters when cash is tight or the market is uncertain. Present both and let the board apply its own rule.

How long should the appraisal period be?

Match it to the useful life of the equipment and the company’s depreciation policy. Ten years is a common choice for production lines. If the product the line is built for has a shorter life in the market, use that instead.

Should the figures include inflation?

Either approach works if it is applied consistently. Use nominal cash flows with a nominal discount rate, or real cash flows with a real rate. Mixing them distorts the result.

How long does it take to model a line before the decision?

We can build a working model of your plant in 48 hours from line data, cycle times and the product mix, then test the investment options against it.

Related guides

Test your investment in a model